Simon Holmes à Court comments in The Guardian (17.9.20) on the federal government's 'gas-fired recovery' plan to underpin the economic pathway out of the pandemic crisis. The author suggests that the Coalition's 'increasingly desperate and ideological energy market interventions' will end up costing us all.
'On Tuesday evening as I was streaming BP’s annual energy outlook statement – wherein the oil “supermajor” explained that fossil fuels have likely peaked and energy growth from here on in will be renewables, renewables and more renewables – a news notification popped up on my screen: Australian minister for energy and emissions reduction Angus Taylor demands electricity sector builds new 1,000 MW gas fired power station.
'An astoundingly bad idea, on so many levels.
'With the closure of the Liddell coal fired power station in the Hunter Valley, the federal government doesn’t want a repeat of Hazelwood.
'… Since gas, as a fuel, costs around three times as much as the equivalent amount of coal, power from gas costs a lot more than from coal. If a new gas power station were to run around the clock, it might be able to produce electricity for as low as $90 per megawatt hour, almost twice as much as current long term power contracts. A “like for like” gas replacement of Liddell would make a multi-billion dollar loss over its lifetime. Won’t happen.
'In general, gas power stations are run much more sporadically, only during peak demand events. If the mooted gas power station were to run only as a peaking plant, the cost of energy produced could easily be twice as high again.'
- Angus Taylor's gas plan is an astoundingly bad idea, on so many levels »
- Does Scott Morrison's 'go-with-gas' recovery plan promise more than it can deliver? »
- Grattan on Friday: Morrison signs up to the gas gospel, but the choir is not in tune »
- Morrison government threatens to use Snowy Hydro to build gas generator, as it outlines 'gas-fired recovery' plan »
- No, Prime Minister, gas doesn't 'work for all Australians' and your scare tactics ignore modern energy problems »
- 4 reasons why a gas-led economic recovery is a terrible, naive idea »
- Phasing out gas would benefit Australian manufacturers and households »
- Sinking billions of taxpayer dollars into gas would make Australia an international pariah »
- Malcolm Turnbull condemns Scott Morrison's 'gas, gas, gas' song as 'a fantasy' »
- The Coalition's plan to use gas to stimulate manufacturing will fail »
- Labor agrees to support new gas projects after public brawl sparked by Joel Fitzgibbon »
- Benefits of Coalition's 'gas-led recovery' overstated and declining usage inevitable, report finds »
- Gas won't fuel Australia's recovery or reduce emissions. It's a mirage »
- Federal government gives environmental approval to controversial $3.6bn Narrabri gas project »
- 'Unjustifiable': new report shows how the nation's gas expansion puts Australians in harm's way »
- 'Zero return': government savaged over taxpayer grants to open up new gas basin in Australia »