TJ Ryan Foundation Research Associate, John Quiggin, and Richard Holden write in The Conversation (9.7.21) that a majority of Australian economists are supportive of lockdowns as a health response to the Covid-19 pandemic, despite the immediate economic impacts.
‘With the prospect of a lengthier lockdown looming over Sydney, the idea of “living with the virus” has resurfaced.
‘NSW’s health minister, Brad Hazzard, raised the prospect of abandoning the lockdown and accepting that “the virus has a life which will continue in the community” at a press conference on Wednesday. NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian and Prime Minister Scott Morrison have rejected that idea, but many voices in the media have been pushing it.
‘As with pandemic policy in general, much of the discussion of the Sydney outbreak has framed the problem as one pitting health against the economy. In this framing, epidemiologists and public health experts are seen as the advocates of saving lives, while economists are seen as the advocates of saving money.
‘In reality, the great majority of Australian economists support policies of aggressive suppression or elimination – that is, keeping case numbers close to zero, and clamping down when an outbreak threatens.’
- Why most economists continue to back lockdowns »
- Yes, lockdowns are costly. But the alternatives are worse »
- Go hard, go home: Study finds lockdowns save money in the long run »
- Open letter from 222 Australian economists: don’t sacrifice health for ‘the economy’ »
- As Sydney’s lockdown continues, what support is available – and needed – for people losing income? »
- Income support for casual workers essential to avoid extended Sydney lockdown, unions say »
- One failure too many »
- Does one size fit all? »
- Zero-COVID is no longer an effective strategy. We need to learn from other countries how to adapt »
- Hundreds of thousands of people financially worse off in 2021 lockdowns »
- Through rolling lockdowns, Australians are keeping calm and carrying on – even as we lose hope in our leaders »
- Lock down smarter, not harder »
- As Omicron spreads, it’s bad news for the 2022 economy as COVID stirs fear – again »
- What the ‘let it rip’ COVID strategy has meant for Indigenous and other immune-compromised communities »
- Covid control: How this man remains the most powerful figure in Queensland »
- Lockdowns doubled your risk of mental health symptoms »
- Many places are starting to wind back COVID restrictions, but this doesn’t mean the pandemic is over yet »
- Australia’s post-war recovery program provides clues as to how to get out of this »
- We have a right to expect government to do what markets cannot: social and economic protection for all of us »